Yesterday was another torrential rainstorm. Fanta grabbed me with words of "old woman" and "fever," and we went to see the old dying woman. We met up with Sangare, the doctor, who gave the unsuprising diagnosis - malaria - which is literally ravaging our village this time of year during the rainy season. We found her under bright purple sheets sown with green flowers, her shallow breaths contrasting with the feverent pumping rain. When it died down for a moment, she got up and walked, shakily gripping the walls as we sat shelling peanuts. As she reached the nyegen she looked back vacantly as the wind played games with her green headwrap. Her grip on the mud wall seemed to teeter between worlds, her stare exhausted and vacant. The next day I went out to the peanut fields with Fanta and a few other women. Our hands and heads and backs were filled with gourd bowls, radios, water jugs and little girls. We sat under a tree and pulled the peanuts from the roots as we exchanged warm but confused sentiments about farming and the village. Our picinic lunch of fresh sweet milk with millet and cut cucumber was refreshing, and I finally felt welome into this community of strong women, even though they make constantly make fun of my smooth uncalloused hands and lack of a husband. We left as again the black clouds rolled in, and ran the last half kilometer to the village as the rain slowly crept up on our heads.
I returned after the fields to give my blessings to the old woman, and then went to sit with Nasira as she cooked dinner - peanut sauce and to (ground millet patties) over a mud fire pit. The next morning the old woman had died. Fanta had no tears as she told me - she went on pounding millet. Of course, she had eleven children, another wife and a husband to feed.
Wednesday, October 28, 2009
10/13/09 ? I am losing track of the days...
Today I woke up after dreams of lying in Central Park listening to Belle and Sebastian with Gabby, a Starbucks white mocha frappaccino in hand. I was shocked to find myself under a mosquito net and a straw roof, listening to the donkeys morning wheeze. And there is no jarring sound like the donkeys first sounds in the morning - raggedly sucking in air in a tension filled shudder, and as soon as it seems like the poor malnourished beast's lungs have collapsed, it haws out a shrill choked exhale. Most of the day was spent in my usual way: mornings in the health center weighing babies, afternoon tea with the CSCOM staff, cooking lunch and studying Bambara as a crowd of aimless children stare at me, the evening tea and chat sessions followed by dinner with my host family. Still, I felt I was looking at my village through raw eyes, everything highlighted by the vibrant blue and yellow outlines that my anti-malaria medication fabricates. This is where I live? These are my neighbors, my friends, my co-workers? These straw huts with the swirling squash and cucumber vines - this is my home? What a strange, beautiful, simple world to be living in, so unlike the crisp, metallic New York! Even though the people asking me for money piss me off, the children laughing at my terrible Bambara is exasperating, and I haven't quite figured out how to successfully carry my water buckets on my head without getting soaking wet, its wonderful to live so intimately in this village. And despite the frequent loneliness that comes with being an outsider, and my (daily) efforts to get the children away who constantly swarm to my house (which is facing the school), I am amazed at how much I've integrated into the community in a month.
One thing I've been doing alot of is baby weighings at the CSCOM. During vaccination days on Mondays, women of the surrounding villages come, and I've tried to take this opportunity to weigh the 30+ babies there. In addition, almost daily children come to the CSCOM, for whatever reason, who are obviously malnourished. I've found that about 8 out of 10 children I've weighed are malnourished, either moderately or severely. Plumpy Nut, an ameliorated peanut butter distributed by UNICEF, has been a really helpful way to ensure that they are getting their daily protien and vitamin quota, which is so lacking in the typical Malian diet of rice and millet. But the French charts and guidelines are contradictory and confusing to me, and even more so to the other healthcare workers who seem to arbitrarily prescribe the peanut butter and make unconfident suggestions to the clueless parents. There is definitely something to the argument that literature and funding is great in terms of aid to developing countries, but taking the time to actually train the health workers in the rural villages is desperately needed, and inherently more sustainable than throwing money at a problem.
Saturday, October 17, 2009
Where There is No Gynecologist
Preventing cervical cancer in low resource settings
By Dina Carlin
"Women are not dying because of diseases we cannot treat...they are dying because societies have yet to make the decision that their lives are worth saving."
-Dr. Mahmoud Fathalla, former president of the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics
In a country where female reproductive health is barely on the agenda, cervical cancer is an example of how modern medicine has stopped short in Mali, largely due to the low availability of resources. Each year there are 500,000 new cases of cervical cancer worldwide, and more than 80% of these cases occur in developing countries (1). According to the World Health Organization, cervical cancer is the most frequent cancer developed in Malian women, with 1,336 new cases each year. Meanwhile, 1,076 cases of cervical cancer in Mali each year result in death. These figures are projected to double in the next 15 years (2). While these statistics are sobering, cervical cancer happens to be one of the most preventable cancers with even infrequent screening. A household condiment, it seems, may be the answer.
The development of cervical cancer, caused by certain strains of the sexually transmitted virus HPV (the Human Papiloma Virus), has been strongly linked to socio-economic status. The increased prevalence of HPV in developing countries, as compared to rates in developed nations, is linked to a comprehensive list of factors, including access to sexual education, age of first sexual intercourse (25% of Malian women have sex before the age of 15), and availability of medical resources. However, the high incidence of cervical cancer is in large due to the lack of access to preventative healthcare. It is estimated that 21.5% of women in West Africa are infected with HPV, and this number has been climbing. In developed countries with fluid, accessible medical technology, the 'Pap' smear, a standard part of a gynecological exam, followed by colposcopy (laboratory analysis of cervical tissue) are well established methods to screen for HPV and precancerous cells. In addition, a vaccine that prevents two strains of HPV most frequently associated with cervical cancer has recently become widely available, albeit expensive. These efforts have led to sharp decreases in cervical cancer worldwide, with the exception of Sub-Saharan Africa. The high cost of these procedures, untrained and inexperienced healthcare providers, and the need for follow-up treatment create obvious barriers for impoverished countries such as Mali.
New procedures for diagnosing cervical cancer have been founded on the need for inexpensive screening methods that require minimal training and single visits to the health center. Since cervical cancer generally develops slowly, screening every 3-5 years, sources say, can have a significant impact in reducing mortality (3). While not as effective as the Pap smear, and certainly not as empirical as cytology, VIA, or visual inspection of the cervix with acetic acid (also known as household vinegar) is a groundbreaking alternative for the developing world. An alternative is VILA, visual inspection with Lugol's iodine, which is a slightly more expensive alternative. It involves only spraying the vinegar or iodine on the cervix, where the precancerous cells turn white in the case of vinegar, or brown with iodine. The simplicity of this procedure involves almost no equipment other than vinegar (widely available in most butigis) or iodine, and can be administered by any health worker.
Treatment for cervical cancer is key, as 95% of cases become fatal within two years. While treatment options vary, one of the cheapest, easiest and quickest treatments for cervical cancer is cytology, which involves "freezing" the cervix using carbon dioxide or nitrogen dioxide, killing off the precancerous cells. Most of the materials are locally available, the training is minimal, and the 15 minute procedure can be carried out by non-clinicians such as Matrons. In addition, it has a very low rate of complications, with cure rates of 85-91% (1).
So what do we do now? Since sustainability is key, working towards training healthcare workers such as Matrones to screen and treat cancer would decrease the impact of this highly destructive cancer. Finally, education and screening initiatives, with the aid of NGOs such as Prevent International Cervical Cancer Now (www.pincc.org) or the Alliance for Cervical Cancer Prevention would help bring the issue of cervical cancer to the national spotlight. Turning to simple and accessible technologies such as VIA and cryotherapy can create the foundation for effective preventative care in reproductive medicine. With all the tools available here in Mali to fight cervical cancer, it is time to decide to take action.
1 Sanghvi H., Lacoste M and McCormick M (eds). (2006). Preventing Cercical Cancer in Low-Resources Settings: From Research to Practice. Report of a conference in Bangkok, Thialand, 4-7 December 2005. JHPIGO: Baltimore, Maryland.
2 WHO/ICO Information Centre on HPV and Cervical Cancer (HPV Information Centre). (2009). Human Papillomavirus and Related Cancers in Mali: Summary Report 2009. [Accessed October 2, 2009]. Available at www. who. int/ hpvcentre
3 Sankaranarayanan,R.,Budukh, A. M. and Rajkumar, R. (2001). Effective screening programmes for cervical cancer in low- and middle-income developing countries. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. WHO.
By Dina Carlin
"Women are not dying because of diseases we cannot treat...they are dying because societies have yet to make the decision that their lives are worth saving."
-Dr. Mahmoud Fathalla, former president of the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics
In a country where female reproductive health is barely on the agenda, cervical cancer is an example of how modern medicine has stopped short in Mali, largely due to the low availability of resources. Each year there are 500,000 new cases of cervical cancer worldwide, and more than 80% of these cases occur in developing countries (1). According to the World Health Organization, cervical cancer is the most frequent cancer developed in Malian women, with 1,336 new cases each year. Meanwhile, 1,076 cases of cervical cancer in Mali each year result in death. These figures are projected to double in the next 15 years (2). While these statistics are sobering, cervical cancer happens to be one of the most preventable cancers with even infrequent screening. A household condiment, it seems, may be the answer.
The development of cervical cancer, caused by certain strains of the sexually transmitted virus HPV (the Human Papiloma Virus), has been strongly linked to socio-economic status. The increased prevalence of HPV in developing countries, as compared to rates in developed nations, is linked to a comprehensive list of factors, including access to sexual education, age of first sexual intercourse (25% of Malian women have sex before the age of 15), and availability of medical resources. However, the high incidence of cervical cancer is in large due to the lack of access to preventative healthcare. It is estimated that 21.5% of women in West Africa are infected with HPV, and this number has been climbing. In developed countries with fluid, accessible medical technology, the 'Pap' smear, a standard part of a gynecological exam, followed by colposcopy (laboratory analysis of cervical tissue) are well established methods to screen for HPV and precancerous cells. In addition, a vaccine that prevents two strains of HPV most frequently associated with cervical cancer has recently become widely available, albeit expensive. These efforts have led to sharp decreases in cervical cancer worldwide, with the exception of Sub-Saharan Africa. The high cost of these procedures, untrained and inexperienced healthcare providers, and the need for follow-up treatment create obvious barriers for impoverished countries such as Mali.
New procedures for diagnosing cervical cancer have been founded on the need for inexpensive screening methods that require minimal training and single visits to the health center. Since cervical cancer generally develops slowly, screening every 3-5 years, sources say, can have a significant impact in reducing mortality (3). While not as effective as the Pap smear, and certainly not as empirical as cytology, VIA, or visual inspection of the cervix with acetic acid (also known as household vinegar) is a groundbreaking alternative for the developing world. An alternative is VILA, visual inspection with Lugol's iodine, which is a slightly more expensive alternative. It involves only spraying the vinegar or iodine on the cervix, where the precancerous cells turn white in the case of vinegar, or brown with iodine. The simplicity of this procedure involves almost no equipment other than vinegar (widely available in most butigis) or iodine, and can be administered by any health worker.
Treatment for cervical cancer is key, as 95% of cases become fatal within two years. While treatment options vary, one of the cheapest, easiest and quickest treatments for cervical cancer is cytology, which involves "freezing" the cervix using carbon dioxide or nitrogen dioxide, killing off the precancerous cells. Most of the materials are locally available, the training is minimal, and the 15 minute procedure can be carried out by non-clinicians such as Matrons. In addition, it has a very low rate of complications, with cure rates of 85-91% (1).
So what do we do now? Since sustainability is key, working towards training healthcare workers such as Matrones to screen and treat cancer would decrease the impact of this highly destructive cancer. Finally, education and screening initiatives, with the aid of NGOs such as Prevent International Cervical Cancer Now (www.pincc.org) or the Alliance for Cervical Cancer Prevention would help bring the issue of cervical cancer to the national spotlight. Turning to simple and accessible technologies such as VIA and cryotherapy can create the foundation for effective preventative care in reproductive medicine. With all the tools available here in Mali to fight cervical cancer, it is time to decide to take action.
1 Sanghvi H., Lacoste M and McCormick M (eds). (2006). Preventing Cercical Cancer in Low-Resources Settings: From Research to Practice. Report of a conference in Bangkok, Thialand, 4-7 December 2005. JHPIGO: Baltimore, Maryland.
2 WHO/ICO Information Centre on HPV and Cervical Cancer (HPV Information Centre). (2009). Human Papillomavirus and Related Cancers in Mali: Summary Report 2009. [Accessed October 2, 2009]. Available at www. who. int/ hpvcentre
3 Sankaranarayanan,R.,Budukh, A. M. and Rajkumar, R. (2001). Effective screening programmes for cervical cancer in low- and middle-income developing countries. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. WHO.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)